Jim Zumbo and some unpleasant truths

The Jim Zumbo kafuffle has been interesting to follow. For anyone not involved with firearm politics, Zumbo, the hunting editor for Outdoor Life magazine made a statement on his Outdoor Life blog that military style semi-auto rifles – black guns or ARs as some like to call them – should not be used for hunting. If he had stopped there he probably would have taken flack but survived. There would have been lots of commentary pro and con, but he wouldn’t have been permanently damaged. But then he made a cardinal error. He called these firearms “terrorist guns”. Much stuff hit the fan.

In the U.S. as in Canada these guns have been demonized by anti-gunners, politicians and the press and owners and gun rights proponents are rightfully paranoid about any attacks on their legitimacy. In Canada, through legislation, many specific makes and models have been classed as “prohibited” and are unavailable for purchase by most licensed gun owners. In the U.S. the Federal Assault Weapons Ban, was removed from legislation as recently as 2004 through a sunset clause. Thus to have a respected and prominent outdoor writer – someone the firearms community considered a friend and supporter –  come out publicly and call them terrorist guns, was in their eyes tantamount to complete and total betrayal.

Although it’s hard to believe, Zumbo didn’t seem to understand the politics of the issue nor did he seem to know that there are countless shooters in the U.S. who shoot these guns, in competition, for hunting and just for the sheer fun of it, and that they are passionate about their right to own these guns.

For those interested in the story, The Shooting Wire has a good a review of how it has all played out to date.

Needless to say, Zumbo has been destroyed by the firestorm that arose in the wake of his comments.

The interesting aspect of this nuclear explosion has been the sense of betrayal being shown by the AR owners and shooters. That’s probably because they are most aware of the fact that if the ‘gun-banners’ ever get into power, their guns will be the first to go. They believe strongly in
Benjamin Franklin’s statement: “We must all hang together, or assuredly we shall hang separately.” Unfortunately for the gun rights cause, whether in Canada or the U.S. that truism isn’t that obvious to all gun owners.

We see it everywhere. Longbow aficionados look down on the compound bow users and they both disavow the crossbow shooter to the point where in many places it is illegal to use a crossbow in a bowhunting season.

But mostly you see it within the firearms community. In Britain the side-by-side and over/under shotgun owners were willing to sell out those who shot with pump guns or self-loaders. Rifle shooters are often all too willing to turn a blind eye to increased legislation against handgun ownership. Even while the emails rolled in skewering Zumbo, there were comments that ARs shouldn’t be used for hunting and that the writer wouldn’t hunt with someone using an AR. So you can figure that if push came to shove there are those amongst us who would sleep with the enemy if they thought it might save their personal shooting style.

And that’s why Zumbo got torched. He gave those AR owners a glimpse of their possible future.

It’s hard to believe that gun owners in general, who are under attack from all directions, can’t understand Mr. Franklin’s statement of fact. If we let them isolate us into separate groups, they will pick us off one by one.


2 Responses to “Jim Zumbo and some unpleasant truths”

  1. Bumper Guy! Says:

    Let me see now . . . this thing has a trigger (firing

    mechanism), a barrel, a stock/grip and it fires projectiles . . . so

    it is called a “gun” which includes everything from a missile

    launcher to a BB gun, be it a pistol, revolver or rifle. It could be

    mounted on an airplane, tank, water vessel or inside your


    The gun banners only focus on “civilian” weapons. But it is

    perfectly OK for these same gun banners to sanction weapons

    of mass destruction! Why? They are either stupid civilians or

    idealogs who want your freedom on a silver platter!

    Americans – Beware of BOTH!

  2. Support your fellow gun owner « Totalrecoil Says:

    […] who can become extremely testy if anyone tries to impact their sport in a negative manner, as witness the destruction of Jim Zumbo’s career when he made the fatal error of saying in his blog that he […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: